This is all true:
They buried the little girl in the hard ground of the Indianapolis winter. Despite the freezing temperatures, her mother stood by the grave for hours after the funeral, weeping to exhaustion in the falling snow. By late afternoon, family had coaxed her away, but she returned to the grave early the next morning and discovered a single white slipper in the dirt next to her daughter’s grave. The mother recognized it immediately: her daughter’s slipper. The slipper she had been buried in.
Grief and horror overwhelmed the mother and she fell to her knees, clutching the slipper tightly. Her screams alarmed nearby police. Hours later, gravediggers discovered the truth: the new grave was empty. It wasn’t a restless spirit or demon that had dropped the slipper there, it was a careless body snatcher.
A century ago, body snatching was big business in central Indiana. A distasteful and illegal practice, body snatching nonetheless provided a substantial income for unscrupulous criminals who sold the bodies to medical schools for lessons in dissection (among them the Indiana Medical College and the Physiomedrical College of Indiana).
The growth of the medical field in the United States after the Civil War led to an abundance of medical schools. While these schools were often well-funded, they liked an essential object for anatomy lessons: actual human anatomy. Bodies only trickled in, with dozens of students watching from a distance in lecture theaters as professors dissected and discussed a single cadaver.
This was common practice for centuries, but during the Civil War, the American medical profession learned the hard way that doctors with rudimentary knowledge of human anatomy could do more harm than good. American medicine began focusing on human anatomy, establishing a scientific and practical approach to medicine. These future professionals needed hands-on experience, and that meant more cadavers. Many more.
Prior to body-snatching, bodies were typically obtained if unclaimed by family, belonged to a jailed individual or, as a final punishment, if the body belonged to an executed individual. Medical schools also received unclaimed residents of nearby mental asylums.
Prices and body snatching techniques varied, but one rule was consistent across the entire sordid industry: the fresher the body, the higher the price. A body buried and stolen in the same night could fetch as much as $50 to $75 dollars, equivalent to $1000 to $1500 dollars today.
After decades of the White River’s flooding, the city of Indianapolis finally admitted Greenlawn Cemetery, one of the city’s first cemeteries, had to be moved to higher, drier ground to prevent a municipal plague. The resting place of the city’s pioneer families and almost 3000 Civil War soldiers, Greenlawn Cemetery sat just west of today’s Lucas Oil Stadium in downtown Indianapolis.
Officials contacted family members and exhumations began. Or what they thought would be exhumations. In grave after grave, coffins and caskets were dug up, only to reveal an empty box containing a pile of clothing. Nothing more. Dozens and then hundreds of empty graves were discovered, with virtually all bodies buried after 1890 gone. The families of Indianapolis wanted blood.
By the time Indiana’s body snatchers operated, their techniques had gone through centuries of improvements, allowing a fresh Hoosier grave to be emptied in less than an hour. Body snatchers, ghouls, or “resurrectionists,” would locate a fresh grave, which made the digging and disguising easier. They would mark the head of the grave and dig a hole one or two feet in diameter straight down.
After reaching the casket or coffin, they’d attach ropes to the exposed lid and, using the dirt’s weight as leverage, yank the rope violently, cracking the lid. The body and valuables would be removed, with only the clothes tossed back into the grave.
They’d quickly fill the hole in again and smooth the mounded dirt, leaving most cemetery guards and family members none the wiser. Professionals often stole several bodies in a single night, typically fresh bodies, but occasional settling for the lower price procured from skeletal remains. They’d then meet a contact at a nearby medical school for payment.